Introductory Statement by
Debapriya Bhattacharya
Executive Director, Centre
for Policy Dialogue (CPD) at the
Publication Launch of the
Collected Works of Rehman Sobhan
Pan Pacific Sonargaon Hotel;
Saturday 24 March 2007
- Your Excellency the Chief
Advisor to the Caretaker
Government and Chief Guest of
the
occasion Dr Fakhruddin Ahmed
- Hon’b le Chairperson and
Member of CPD Board of Trustees
Mr M Syeduzzaman
- Founder and Chairman of the
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
Professor Rehman Sobhan
- Respected Discussants
- Excellencies, Esteemed Guests,
Friends and Colleagues!
We have all assembled here this
afternoon to celebrate the
publication of Collected Works
of Rehman Sobhan. On behalf of
the Centre for Policy Dialogue
(CPD), it is my proud and
pleasant privilege to extend a
warm welcome to all of you on
this unique occasion.
We are extremely grateful for
the kind presence of the Hon’ble
Chief Advisor who has possibly
overstretched himself, given his
current preoccupations, to
register his appreciation for
his former teacher. You perhaps
know that the Hon’ble Chief
Advisor was one of the
illustrious students of
Professor Sobhan’s first batch
in the Dhaka University, better
known as the Batch of 1961.
We are much obliged to the
galaxy of discussants who have
witnessed time, life and works
of Rehman Sobhan from close
quarters. They have generously
agreed to share their
perspectives on this occasion.
We thank the chairperson for
kindly agreeing to preside over
this event.
Finally, we are truly
overwhelmed and greatly inspired
by your enlightened attendance.
Many of you are Professor Rehman
Sobhan’s students and
colleagues, all of you are
Professor Sobhan’s
গুণগ্রাহী
(admirer). We thank you all for
joining us here today.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Today we have gathered here to
commemorate the publication of
an anthology in four volumes
(including one in Bangla)
containing the popular writings
of Professor Rehman Sobhan.
These volumes contain articles,
regular columns in newspapers
and magazines, op-eds, and
interviews by Professor Sobhan.
The companion volume in Bangla
contains a select set of
translated articles. In this
connection, it is necessary to
keep in mind that these four
volumes do not include all the
works of Professor Rehman Sobhan,
only his popular works and that
also the selected ones. These
volumes do not also include his
academic books which are 42 in
number (including 3 in Bangla).
Among the total entries in these
four volumes, numbering 222, the
first one dates as far back as
1961, and the last one is dated
2006. Collating, classifying,
editing, formatting,
illustrating and printing this
enormous volume of literature
from diverse, dispersed (and
often obscure) sources was a
herculean task. Professor Rehman
Sobhan has mentioned in his
dedication of one of the volumes
that “for CPD for whom no
challenge is too great”. Indeed
it is the intellectual passion,
professional innovativeness,
artistic creativity, and sheer
hard labour of my CPD colleagues
which have made this delivery
possible.
The entire CPD family has
contributed in different forms
and varying degrees towards this
publication. I would still like
to single out a few of them. The
unbridled enthusiasm and
revealed commitment of Dr Uttam
Kumar Deb, Senior Research
Fellow, CPD have been the
lifeline of the venture. Mr
Mahboob Hassan, Outreach
Manager, CPD conceived and
managed the content design and
formatting of the publication.
Linguistic talent of Professor
Hayat Mahmud greatly improved
the Bangla rendition. Mr Avra
Bhattacharjee, Documentation
Officer, CPD provided
significant editorial
assistance. Mr Ashok Karmaker
needs to be mentioned for his
artistic inputs. There are many
others and I do not want to bore
you by reading out the CPD staff
list. The entire process was
ably led by Professor Mustafizur
Rahman, Research Director, CPD
and Ms Anisatul Fatema Yousuf,
Additional Director in charge of
Dialogue and Communication
Division, CPD. To all of them I
remain grateful.
I am humbled by the high degree
of professional and personal
commitment demonstrated by my
CPD colleagues towards this
venture. I am proud to be part
of such an extraordinary
collective.
Dear Guests,
On an occasion when you are
confronted with the lifetime
popular works of such an
outstanding scholar as Professor
Sobhan, one is seized by an urge
for introspection. One feels
inclined to take a step back and
assess the context, concerns and
challenges confronting his life
and time.
I reckon his family
circumstances played a big role
in shaping Rehman Sobhan’s
values and attitudes in life.
His mother was an enlightened
member of the Nawab family of
Dhaka. On the other hand, his
father after retiring from the
colonial Indian Police Service
opted for Pakistan and went on
to become the Political
Secretary to the Prime Minister.
Subsequently he served as an
ambassador. His father belongs
to the first generation of
post-Pakistan entrepreneurs who
established one of the first
tannery factories in Dhaka. Born
in 1935 in Kolkata, Rehman
Sobhan grew up at a time when
anti-colonial movement gained
momentum in the sub-continent;
he witnessed the decadence of
the feudal structure, noted the
limits of growth of the new
Muslim middle class and observed
the constrained prospect of the
emerging entrepreneurial class
in the then East Pakistan.
An excellent academic
environment nurtured and
cultivated his natural ability
to critically observe and assess
his surroundings. He associated
himself with the marginalized
social groups on one hand, and
the forces of promise and hope
on the other. Rehman Sobhan’s
alma maters included St. Paul’s
School in Darjeeling, Atchison
College, Lahore and the
Cambridge University, UK. His
subsequent academic pursuits
took him to such institutions as
Oxford and Harvard Universities
and many of the reputed centres
of excellence in the academic
world.
Friends and Colleagues,
Fifty years back, in 1957,
Rehman Sobhan started his
professional career in the
Department of Economics,
University of Dhaka – where he
taught till the beginning of the
War of Independence in 1971. For
many of you, Rehman Sobhan,
first of all, is a teacher who
still pursues his engaging
augmentative style with great
erudition while establishing his
heterodox viewpoints. I do not
know whether through his
teaching Professor Sobhan has
affected eternity or not, but he
has definitely influenced a
number of generations of
students imbibing them with
academic excellence,
nationalistic feelings and often
with a sense of purpose in life.
Excellencies,
For many of us Rehman Sobhan is
a “liberation economist” (as
there are liberation theologists).
He is an economist who devoted
his talent in search of a
socio-economic paradigm which
could liberate the people of
this country from the threats of
ignorance, poverty and
insecurity. Some have complained
that Rehman Sobhan was biased in
his intellectual pursuit. Yes,
biased he was! He was biased
towards the marginalized and the
deprived, voiceless and the
disenfranchised people of this
country. The storyline of all
his works were underpinned by
his quest for social justice,
equity and equal opportunities
for all. He emerged as possibly
one of the most effective
economists in Bangladesh to date
whose political economic
analysis and perspectives will
generate confidence and
enthusiasm for future
generations who will seek to
empower the citizens with their
effective rights.
Friends and Colleagues,
Rehman Sobhan’s bibliography not
only exposes an Odyssey of a
Bangladeshi economist creating
the milestones to independence,
engaging in defining the
development prospect of a newly
born country, but also reflects
the country’s subsequent
struggle for socio-economic
development. His seminal
contribution in formulating the
economic premises for the
independence of Bangladesh,
better known as the “Two
Economies Theory”, is an
achievement that would have been
enough for a life time. But he
never slowed downs. His writings
are a true reflection of the
developmental debate, discourse
and experience that Bangladesh
has passed over the past years.
Thus, we see that major themes
of his works have sequentially
covered such areas as Political
Implications of Food for Works
Programme of Ayub Khan, Role of
Public Enterprise in an
Intermediate Regime, Crisis of
External Dependence, Debt
Default, Agrarian Reform,
Critique of Adjustment Policies
Reforms, Anatomy of
Malgovernance and, finally,
Strategies for Eradication of
Poverty. He was always the first
to address the idea whose time
has come.
He taught us to blend academic
rigour with civic courage. An
example of this was publication
of the monograph ‘A Decade of
Stagnation’ during the heydays
of anti-autocracy movement, a
time when he was the head of
semi-government organization,
the BIDS. We later smuggled the
monograph to the donor
community’s annual aid group
meeting which was being held in
Sonargaon in October 1990. In
fact, he was only 25 when his
article on Economy of East
Pakistan was withdrawn by the
Pakistan Government because it
was found to be politically
unacceptable.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
In this connection we can not
but mention Professor Rehman
Sobhan’s role as a freedom
fighter. He crossed over to
India during the early months of
the Liberation War in 1971 and
was appointed “Envoy
Extraordinary” in charge of
Economic Affairs for the
Provisional Bangladesh
Government in Exile. In this
capacity he was the first
representative of the
Provisional Government to reach
USA in the month of May 1971. He
was the first to address the
leading US Senators to apprise
them about the cause of
Bangladesh. At that time, he had
the unique distinction of
addressing the National Press
Club of Washington D.C., an
honour which is sometimes
accorded to the Heads of States.
Rehman Sobhan continued to
mobilize international opinion
till the Victory Day.
Dear Guests,
While appreciating the role of
individuals, Rehman Sobhan has
always demonstrated his belief
in collective actions. Thus, he
remains one of the successful
institution builders in the
country. Launch of the
post-independence Bangladesh
Planning Commission,
rejuvenation of BIDS in
mid-1980s and founding of CPD in
mid-1990s bear testimony to his
organizational capacity and
leadership qualities. As a
leader, he has always striven to
create and promote people with
conviction and the will to carry
on the task of nation building.
Dear Colleagues and Guests,
Many of you are possibly not
fully aware that Rehman Sobhan
has been and remains a
distinguished personality in the
international development
community. He was a member of
the United Nations Secretary
General’s Committee for
Development Planning, Member of
the Executive Committee of the
International Economics
Association, Member of the
Commission for New Asia, Member
of the Board of UNRISD and the
UN University. He was a member
of the Group of Eminent Persons
set up by SAARC Heads of States
as well as that of the High
Level Panel for the LDCs set up
by UN-ESCAP. His forceful
interventions in various fora
are often respectfully recalled
by those who did not necessarily
agree with his propositions. He
resigned from the famous Volker
Commission, which was headed by
the former Head of the US
Federal Reserve, when he
disagreed with him on his
approach towards restructuring
of multilateral financial
system, arguing for better
resource flow to low income
countries.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
At the end of the day, what
always impresses us is his human
qualities – his noble values and
good manners. His care for his
low paid colleagues,
inconspicuous public charity,
active interest in diverse
issues in life, strength to
suffer personal tragedies
gracefully. Indeed, he has a
deep inner life which allows him
to deal with the irritating
details of the mundane. He finds
time to pick the latest
blockbuster from the DVD store,
and also to pen a long review
after reading Vikram Seth’s ‘A
Suitable Boy’. Many of us who
have learnt our trade at his
feet received a bonus in the
form of appreciation for
pursuing high thoughts with
passionate human interests.
Dear Friends and Colleagues,
One wonders why a man who is
responsible for articulating the
economic rationale for
Bangladesh’s independence
movement, who played an active
international role for the
provisional government, who
shaped the reconstruction and
development policy of
post-independence Bangladesh,
who with his research and policy
works has systematically tried
to create a self-reliant
national economy, who for four
decades has stuck to his guns in
adverse conditions and has
contributed in creating an
independent civil society in
Bangladesh – was never honoured
with a national recognition. On
second thought, it does not come
as a surprise, Professor Sobhan
had always been on the other
side of the barricade – fighting
against the establishment for
development rights of the poor
and the marginalized. He was
always a rebel with a cause.
Thus, his real recognition
emanates from the affection and
respect of his students,
colleagues and conscious
citizens at large. To quote
Voltaire, “It is to him who
masters our mind by the force of
truth, not to those who enslave
them by violence (and may I add,
money), that we owe our
reverence”.
It is in this spirit that the
CPD family has paid its humble
tribute to its teacher, mentor
and Guru by publishing these
volumes for present generation
and the posterity. Bangladesh is
going through an unprecedented
phase of its nationhood. We
trust works of Professor Sobhan
will find new relevance in this
challenging and changing times.
Thank you for your attention.